How to teach reading comprehension, grade by grade

Build reading comprehension one layer at a time: first retelling a story in order and naming who, where and what happened, then the main idea, a summary and answers proved with the text's own words, and later inference, comparing accounts and judging sources and arguments.

ArgoLearn's Language Arts courses follow that order from Grade 1 to Grade 8, and each step can be practiced at home with a book from your shelf, a sheet of paper and a few questions.

What each grade adds

The notes on this page come from ArgoLearn's Language Arts courses. In Kindergarten to Grade 2, about one week in three is a week of stories and writing between the phonics weeks. Grade 3 turns the order around halfway through the year, so each week of word study is followed by two of reading and writing, and in Grades 4 and 5 the weeks come in threes: one of word study, then two of reading and writing.

GradeWhat comprehension adds
KindergartenWho and where; storybook or fact book; beginning, middle and end
Grade 1Key details in order; story maps; who is telling; two versions of one tale
Grade 2How a character responds; opinions with evidence from the book; points of view
Grade 3Trait or feeling; narrators; text features; main idea and summary; claims and evidence
Grade 4Inference from two clues; the gist of each section; how texts are built; first-hand and second-hand sources
Grade 5Exact quotation; two central ideas; which evidence supports which claim; many accounts of one event; judging a source
Grade 6A claim and the cited line that proves it; objective summary; theme as a full sentence
Grade 7Where the author stands; how sections build a central idea; whether reasoning holds
Grade 8How an author answers the other side; two central ideas in one text; a story and its versions

Kindergarten and Grade 1: retell it in order

The kindergarten story weeks name who is in a story and where it happens, sort storybooks from fact books, and retell a fable as beginning, middle and end. Grade 1 adds key details, the important parts told again in order with first, next, then and last, and a story map of characters, setting and big events. Later weeks ask who is telling the story, compare two runaway tales, The Gingerbread Boy and Johnny-cake, and follow a character's feelings as they change.

At home: do a small job together, such as making a snack, and name each step as you go. Your child draws the four steps in four boxes and tells the story while pointing at each one. Cut the boxes apart, mix them up, and your child puts them back in order and retells it. With a picture book, fold a page into three boxes headed Who, Where and What happened, and let your child draw each one before retelling the story.

Grade 2: how characters respond, with evidence from the book

Second grade asks how a character responds to a challenge, in what they feel, say and do, and why. An opinion about a story now needs evidence, words or facts from the book, joined to the claim with because and also. Two versions of one old tale are set side by side, and two characters can see the same moment from different points of view.

Grade 3: traits, main idea and summary

Third grade separates a trait, what a character is like most of the time, from a feeling, how the character feels for a moment, and proves each with details from the text using ACE: answer, cite the text, explain. Your child tells a first-person narrator from a third-person one, uses text features such as headings, captions and an index, and learns that a topic only names what a text is about while a main idea tells its big point. A summary gives the main idea and then three key details in order, in your own words, with no opinions.

Later in the year come claims and evidence, where a fact can be checked and an opinion is never evidence, and two texts on one topic, where each fact is sorted by which text said it.

At home: read a story together and stop where a character does or says something important. Your child writes one trait word and one feeling word and points to the words in the book that prove each. With a fact book, read one paragraph aloud, ask for its main idea in one sentence, then name one key detail each.

Grade 4: inference, the gist and how a text is built

Fourth grade names inference: a clue from the text plus what you already know, backed by two pieces of evidence because one clue can fool you. True texts are read section by section, with the gist of each in about ten words, and the gists add up to the central idea of the whole text. Your child learns five ways a text is built (description, sequence, compare and contrast, cause and effect, problem and solution), each with its signal words, and sorts first-hand sources from second-hand ones by asking who made it, when, and whether they were there.

At home: while your child is out of the room, set out three clues, such as a damp towel, swim goggles and an empty water bottle. Your child writes down each clue with what they already know about it, then one sentence that starts with I can infer and gives a reason with because. With an article that has headings, write each section's gist on a sticky note, line the notes up and turn them into one sentence about the whole text.

Grade 5: quote exactly and weigh accounts

Fifth grade separates what a text says outright from what it shows without saying, and a quotation, the writer's exact words inside quotation marks, from a paraphrase, the same idea in new words. Your child finds two central ideas in one text, maps which evidence holds up which reason, sets several accounts of one event side by side to see why they differ, and judges with five tests whether a source is reliable for a given question.

At home: choose a paragraph of three to five sentences. Your child copies one sentence exactly, inside quotation marks, and checks it against the book word by word. Then cover the paragraph while your child says one idea from it in their own words and writes it down with no quotation marks.

Grades 6 to 8: evidence, central ideas and the other side

Sixth grade sets a claim, what you figured out in your own words, apart from evidence, the exact line that proves it, cited with its paragraph number so a reader can check it. A central idea grows section by section, an objective summary keeps the key points in order with no opinions, and a theme is a full sentence about life, not a topic of a word or two.

Seventh grade looks for where the author stands, which is not every view a text reports, and weighs reasoning with three checks: whether the conclusion follows, whether the evidence is about this exact claim, and whether there is enough of it. Eighth grade studies how an author meets the other side, by conceding a point, answering with evidence or narrowing the claim, and compares a story with its versions for stage, screen and sound.

Questions to ask while you read together

The hands-on lessons of Kindergarten to Grade 5 end with questions for the grown-up to ask. These are drawn from them, reworded to fit almost any book:

  • Ask what happened first and what happened last.
  • Ask who the story is about and where it happens, then what the problem was and how it ended.
  • Ask for an opinion about a character, with two reasons from the story.
  • Ask what a paragraph is mostly about, and which detail tells more about it.
  • Ask what a second book on the same topic added, and where the two agree.
  • Ask whether one clue could fool you, and why two clues are better than one.
  • Ask how your child checked that a quotation was exact.

Using ArgoLearn for reading comprehension

Each ArgoLearn Language Arts course is a 180-lesson year that teaches phonics or word study beside reading and writing, with Story Time lessons from well-known books and tales in every grade. With a free family account you can try Lessons 1 to 5 of any grade before you pay.

Questions parents ask

Is reading comprehension taught in kindergarten?
In ArgoLearn's kindergarten, yes: about one week in three is a story week, where your child names the characters and the setting, tells a storybook from a fact book and retells a fable in order.
What is the difference between a main idea and a summary?
The main idea is the most important point of a text or of one part of it. A summary is a short telling in your own words: the main idea first, then the key details in order, with no small details and no opinions.
How do I teach inference?
Treat it as a clue plus what your child already knows. Set out real clues at home, or stop at a page of a picture book where a feeling is not named and ask for two clues from the words, since one clue can fool you.